Intermediary Vs Publisher

Source: Scroll

Context: The Union government has issued a notice to Wikipedia questioning its status as an intermediary under the IT Act, citing complaints of biases and editorial control.

About Intermediary (as per the IT Act):

  • Definition: Entities that store, receive, or transmit information created by third parties.
  • Criteria: To qualify, they must not have editorial control over content and should not create content directly.
  • Liability Shield: Intermediaries are not liable for third-party content hosted on their platforms.
  • Due Diligence: They must ensure illegal content is not posted by users and adhere to the IT Rules.
  • Penalization: If found failing to meet these standards, intermediaries’ risk being classified as publishers, which can expose them to criminal liabilities.

About Publisher (as per the IT Act):

  • Definition: Entities that produce, edit, or publish original content.
  • Criteria: Publishers have control over what content appears on their platforms and are involved in content creation.
  • Liability: Publishers are fully responsible for all content and are open to legal actions based on that content.
  • Due Diligence: Publishers must comply with regulations but are directly liable for any defamatory, inaccurate, or unlawful content.
  • Penalization: They face criminal penalties for content violations, such as defamation or misinformation, since they hold editorial authority.

Insta links: