Revisiting two cases of medico deaths

GS Paper 4

Syllabus: Ethics: Role of family, society and educational institutions in inculcating values

 

Source: The Hindu

 Context: A first-year postgraduate medical student at the Kakatiya Medical College Dr Preethi was reportedly harassed by a male senior, following which she tried to end her life.

 

About Ragging:

Ragging, also known as hazing refers to the practice of subjecting new students to humiliating or abusive behaviour as a way of initiating them into a group or community.

  • Ragging can take many forms, including physical and emotional abuse, harassment, bullying, and even sexual assault.
  • Apart from ragging, hazing, fagging, bullying, pledging and horseplaying are different terms.

 

 

 

Previous instances of ragging in India:

  TAMIL NADU – PON NAVARASU

  • Tamil Nadu passed the country’s first anti-ragging legislation in 1997 based on the Pon Navarasu case.
  • Navarasu, son of the-then vice-chancellor of the University of Madras, was murdered. John David, a senior student of his college, confessed to the crime days later and surrendered to judicial custody.
  • During a ragging session, Navarasu was assaulted, and forced to strip and lick David’s footwear, he was violently beaten up and killed when he refused to do so.

 MAHARASHTRA – Payal Tadvi

  • Payal Tadvi, a second-year MD student at Mumbai’s TN Topivala National Medical College (TNMC), had spoken to her friends about caste discrimination and harassment within the campus. 
  • She belonged to the Adivasi Tadvi Bhil community and was found dead in Mumbai.

 

Data on caste discrimination in colleges:

  • A parliamentary panel found rampant caste bias within All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), as MBBS students from Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes failed repeatedly in their exams. 
  • The examiners tend to ask the name of the students and try to judge/ know if a student belongs to SC/ST community.

 

Laws against ragging in India:

  • Indian Penal Code
  • UGC Regulations on Curbing the Menace of Ragging in Higher Educational Institutions, 2009
  • Other institute-specific regulations

  

Ethical issues associated with ragging:

  • Violation of human dignity
  • Infringement of individual rights
  • Promotion of unhealthy behaviour
  • Compromise of academic standards
  • The legal and moral responsibility of educational institutions

  

Solutions:

  • Strict rules and regulations
  • Awareness campaigns
  • Counselling and support
  • Orientation programs
  • Monitoring and surveillance