Print Friendly, PDF & Email

7) As an SDM you have received a complaint that in a village under your jurisdiction, people belonging to a religious community who are in majority there (this community is a minority in the state and country) are constructing an illegal religious structure on village common land. It is nearing completion.  The complaint is filed by a local leader belonging to a community who are in minority (majority in the state and country) in the village. You have verified the complaint and found that indeed the structure is being illegally constructed on village common land. You also find that this structure is funded by local MLA. You had issued a show cause notice to the trust that’s constructing the structure asking them why it shouldn’t be demolished. They have replied that a Panchayat of villagers (not official Gram Sabha) was convened and it had decided to construct the structure for the community purpose as they didn’t have a proper place for prayers and congregation. They have also replied that they are willing to pay the fine if the government decides to impose any and have ardently requested not to order demolition as it might lead to communal clashes in the village. The issue is sensitive as majority of the village wants it constructed at any cost. As SDM how will you proceed to resolve the issue?(250 words)

Topic: case study.

7) As an SDM you have received a complaint that in a village under your jurisdiction, people belonging to a religious community who are in majority there (this community is a minority in the state and country) are constructing an illegal religious structure on village common land. It is nearing completion.  The complaint is filed by a local leader belonging to a community who are in minority (majority in the state and country) in the village. You have verified the complaint and found that indeed the structure is being illegally constructed on village common land. You also find that this structure is funded by local MLA.

You had issued a show cause notice to the trust that’s constructing the structure asking them why it shouldn’t be demolished. They have replied that a Panchayat of villagers (not official Gram Sabha) was convened and it had decided to construct the structure for the community purpose as they didn’t have a proper place for prayers and congregation. They have also replied that they are willing to pay the fine if the government decides to impose any and have ardently requested not to order demolition as it might lead to communal clashes in the village.

The issue is sensitive as majority of the village wants it constructed at any cost. As SDM how will you proceed to resolve the issue?(250 words)

Ethics by Lexicon publications

Why this question:

The case study is based on the ethical dilemma.

Key demand of the question:

The answer must sufficiently address the demands of the case study by analyzing the involved ethical perspectives.

Structure of the answer:

Introduction: 

Begin by appreciating the case study, what are the issues involved, who are the stakeholders etc. 

Body:

The question Infront of SDM is about following a balanced approach by understanding the sentiments of the majority community and at the same time giving justice to the minority community.

Students must analyse all possible issues and concerns, write a step by step solution ensuring the concerns of all the stakeholders are taken into account and a solution is provided for which is best fits all. The solution must resonate ethics and morals.

Conclusion:

Conclude by need for strong ethical values, uprightness required by the SDM to take steps in the right directions.